Is my logic not logical?
Sunday, March 18th, 2007Craigslist is full of wonder sometimes.
Someone had posted a list of 25 Disney VHS movie titles for sale, and listed $3.00 each, or 4 for $10.00
And I had asked if I could purchase 10 of the 25 movies for $20, seeing as how I’m always looking to get the prices of things I purchase a little lower than advertised. And in my logic I figured that if 4 movies were $10.00, and that would mean the movies were $2.50 each if sold in lots of four, that should equate to the fact that I wanted 10 movies, and a greater discount should apply meaning my $2.00 per movie was not an unreasonable request. Sure it was a low price, but the dude started pretty low, and when dealing in Craigslist and attempting to sell multiple items, it’s always best to deal with one person interested in as many items as possible. Makes everyone’s lives easier.
Dude comes back to me with the fact that 3 of the titles are now gone and there’s 7 movies left. But he wanted $18.00 for them. And I’m staring at this, and wondering where on earth this number came from. Because at $2.50 per movie, 7 movies should only cost me $17.50, not $18.00. So I countered. As is my custom. I figured $15.00 for 7 movies was also a fair price. Also a number easily reached in cash money. That would have been $2.15 per movie, 15 cents per movie more than I really wanted to pay, but someone beat me to a few movies I was looking for. It was still 7 movies I was taking off this dude’s hands.
But he comes back to me saying the movies he should be selling to me for $19.00, but was giving me “a deal” of going as low as $17.00. And I think about this some more. $19.00 for 7 movies is $2.72 per movie. Which is 22 cents more than the $2.50 per movie he had advertised on his Craigslist advertisement. And I didn’t understand it. Why am I paying more per movie to buy more movies than if I purchased less? Shouldn’t volume count for such transactions? It normally does everywhere else.
And I explained my logic to him. Wondering why he thought 7 movies was worth $19.00 if 8 movies is worth $20.00 and why the amount per movies magically bounces between $2.50 and $2.74 when I want to purchase more from him, not less.
This is what the guy comes back with. His plan is to sell me 4 movies for the advertised price of $10.00 for a lot of four. And then 3 movies at $3.00 each which is how he came to the total of $19.00. And then to be thrilling and exciting he would take off 2 dollars from that total coming down to a $17.00, which is a whopping 50 cents less than his advertised price which works out to $2.50 per movie.
AND comes back at me saying if I went to a store which sells used goods the movies I am looking to purchase are $7-10 each.
So I wrote back. I explained my logic one more time. I explained that in my opinion it is easier dealing with one person purchasing 7 movies, than 7 people purchasing 1 movie each, and that trying to deal with 7 people is not worth the few extra dollars you would get rather than making a deal with one person. And I explained to him the magical world of flea markets, garage sales and other online advertisements similar to his.
And now I’ve blogged about this, because I just find stupidity to be just that funny.

